Back to News Archive

December 10, 2004

DNR reports perfect hunter safety record in ’04

DNR Fisheries drops proposed bass regulation for Namakan Reservoir

DNR announces walleye regulation changes for some Itasca County lakes

Some restaurants may not be serving walleye as marketed

At age 96, Backus man is still hunting

 

DNR reports perfect hunter safety record in ’04
Hunting continues to get safer in Minnesota

DNR Reports
The Minnesota Department of Natural Resources (DNR) reported a perfect hunter safety record in 2004.

For the second time in six years, there were no fatalities during small game, big game, waterfowl, wild turkey and prairie chicken hunting seasons in the state. Only a dozen non-fatal hunting-related accidents occurred this year, a 50 percent reduction compared with last year.

A DNR official says safety is very important to Minnesota hunters.

“Hunting is one of the most valued traditions in Minnesota and is safer than ever, thanks in large part to the DNR’s hunter education programs,” said Captain Mike Hammer, DNR Enforcement education program coordinator.

Through these programs, 3,500 volunteer instructors have taught nearly one million hunters how to properly handle a firearm, outdoor survival skills and Minnesota’s basic hunting safety laws.

Those safety laws require all hunters born after Dec. 31, 1979 to take a DNR firearm safety training class, emphasize the importance of wearing blaze orange and prohibit hunters from having a loaded firearm in a motor vehicle.

As a result of these laws and others, the number of hunting accidents has decreased considerably since firearm safety training was mandated in 1955. In the 1960s, for example, Minnesota averaged 14 hunting fatalities per year and 110 non-fatal accidents. In the past 10 years, hunting accidents dropped to two fatalities and 35 non-fatal accidents annually.

The DNR sold more than 500,000 hunting licenses in 2004, resulting in millions of hunter recreation days across the state. Conservation officers said fewer and fewer hunting incidents occur each year, which is a strong indication that the state’s hunter education programs, including youth firearms safety, advanced hunter education, Minnesota bowhunter education, as well as bear, turkey and deer hunting clinics, are working.

“While we hate to see any incidents at all, when you compare the number of hunters and the amount of time they spend in the field with no fatalities and a dozen non-fatal incidents, it tells us that we are getting through to hunters with our safety message,” said DNR Chief Conservation Officer Mike Hamm. “Because of the quality of our programs and commitment of our volunteer instructors, we are confident that the trend of fewer incidents will continue into the future.”

The DNR is always looking for experienced hunters to pass on the tradition of hunting safety and responsibility to the next generation. If you are interested in joining DNR in this rewarding volunteer activity, call 1-800-366-8917 for information on becoming an instructor, or visit the DNR Web site at www.dnr.state.mn.us

“These people dedicate their personal time to teach the skills of safe and responsible hunting to help make the sport safer,” Hamm said. As a result of hunter education courses, hunting today is safer than many outdoor activities. Based on the number of people seeking emergency-room treatment for sports injuries, The National Safety Council reports that hunting has fewer injuries per 100,000 people participating than football, baseball, cycling, volleyball, swimming, golf, tennis, fishing, bowling, badminton, billiards and ping-pong.

Back to top


DNR Fisheries drops proposed bass regulation for Namakan Reservoir

The International Falls Area Fisheries office announced Wednesday, Dec. 1 that it would not implement a protective size regulation for bass on Namakan Reservoir due to lack of support from the public.

A 12-inch maximum size limit for largemouth and smallmouth bass was proposed for Kabetogama, Namakan, Sand Point, Crane and Little Vermilion lakes. The proposal was aimed at maintaining and improving the quality bass fishery that currently exists on these lakes. Although many anglers currently practice voluntary catch and release, bass harvest has been increasing. Increased harvest could eventually reduce the size of fish available to anglers, with fewer opportunities to encounter trophy-sized bass.

The Namakan Reservoir proposal was part of a statewide initiative to maintain and improve Minnesota’s walleye, bass, crappie and sunfish populations through a simplified set of possession limits and length-based regulations. The decision to drop the Namakan Reservoir proposal followed a year of discussions with stakeholders and a public meeting in Orr in September.

Although some anglers favored increased protection for bass in the Reservoir, most of those who participated in the public input process were opposed to the proposal. Some felt the proposed regulation was too restrictive, while others were afraid that maintaining a quality bass fishery would have a negative affect on the walleye population. Quality bass fisheries have never been demonstrated to negatively affect walleye populations.

Kevin Peterson, Area Fisheries Supervisor at International Falls said, “This isn’t a conservation issue; it’s a question of what kind of bass fishery anglers want.” Peterson went on to say, “It seems that most anglers are satisfied with the bass fishery that currently exists, and there is little interest in taking a conservative approach to managing this bass fishery. Therefore, we decided to drop the proposal.”

Back to top


DNR announces walleye regulation changes for some Itasca County lakes

The Grand Rapids Area Fisheries office announced on Monday, Dec. 6 the decision to implement walleye harvest regulations on seven lakes throughout Itasca County.

“Public support for the 17- to 26-inch protected slot on Swan, Splithand, Trout (near Coleraine), Moose (near Deer River), Round (near Squaw Lake), Deer/Battle/Pickerel (near Effie), and Island (near Northome) was very good so we decided to implement the regulation beginning on May 14, 2005,” said Chris Kavanaugh, Area Fisheries Supervisor. “For Sand, Bowstring and Jessie there was a lack of support so the regulation will not be implemented at this time.”

These proposals were part of a statewide initiative to maintain and improve recreational fisheries using a “tool-box” of simplified regulation options. The decision to implement or drop the proposals was based on comments received between May and early October, and two public meetings held in September.

Signs were posted at access points and at resorts informing anglers of the proposals and requesting comments. “We asked anglers what they thought about the proposals,” said Kavanaugh, “and 528 people responded with calls, letters, or e-mails. Additionally, 67 people came to the public meetings and made comments.”

The comments represent a diverse group of individual anglers. For most lakes anglers supported the regulation because they have seen the benefits at Winnibigoshish and other regulated waters and they felt we needed to do something to conserve or improve these fisheries. Comments in opposition were generally related to the feeling that this proposal was too restrictive, catered to some other group of anglers, or they felt it wasn’t necessary.

Signs will be posted at the accesses on lakes reminding anglers of the change. “We will step up our monitoring efforts on those lakes to keep track of changes in the fish population in order to assess the effectiveness of the regulation,” said Kavanaugh.

Sand, Bowstring, and Jessie will also be monitored regularly to see if any changes are noted there as well.

For more information on the regulation changes please feel free to contact the Grand Rapids Area Fisheries Office at 1201 E. Highway 2, Grand Rapids, MN 55744, (218) 327-4430 or e-mail chris.kavanaugh@dnr.state.mn.us.

Back to top


Some restaurants may not be serving walleye as marketed


MINNEAPOLIS (AP) – Some Twin Cities restaurants that list walleye on their menus may be pulling a bait and switch on their customers.

Instead of serving walleye, a handful of restaurants are serving up a related fish species from eastern Europe called zander, according to an investigation by KARE television.

In recent weeks, television station employees ordered walleye at more than a dozen restaurants in the Twin Cities, and samples of those meals were shipped to a private laboratory in New York for DNA testing.

The tests showed that the “Beer Battered Walleye” on the menu at Spectators Grille & Bar in Savage was really zander. The “Northwoods Walleye” at the Sunshine Factory Restaurant and Bistro in New Hope was zander. And Maynard’s Restaurant in Excelsior, which advertises walleye as its specialty, also served up zander.

And the list goes on.

Some of the restaurants said they thought they were purchasing walleye from their distributors. But others say money may be an explanation, as zander is cheaper than walleye.

“I can understand the incentive, but I don’t agree with it,” said Brad Rebers, a manager at Tavern on Grand in St. Paul. DNA tests showed the walleye a KARE employee ordered there was the real thing.

Tavern on Grand sells 50,000 pounds of walleye a year. Based on walleye and zander prices quoted by a Minneapolis fish distributor, Tavern on Grand could save $2 per pound by switching to zander, for a potential savings of $100,000 per year.

But Rebers said he wouldn’t do it.

“I think you jeopardize your business in the long run if you do that,” he said.

Walleye produces income for a thousand commercial fishermen on Canada’s Lake Winnipeg, and Minnesota consumes more walleye than any other state, KARE reported last week.

The U.S. Food and Drug Administration said such “species substitution” is against the law.

The FDA publishes a list of acceptable market names for fish sold in the United States. Walleye, for example, can be legally sold as walleye or walleye pike. But the FDA does not allow zander to be sold as walleye.

Andrew Simons, the curator of fishes at the Bell Museum of Natural History at the University of Minnesota, said the lineage that led to the walleye and the lineage that led to the zander split about 12 million years ago.

“They are definitely different species,” he said.

Other places where advertised walleye turned out to be zander: Majors Sports Cafe in Woodbury; Jake’s Sports Cafe in Crystal; and the St. Croix Casino in Turtle Lake, Wis.

Ryan Wentz, a vice president for the Majors and Spectators restaurant chains, said his chef purchased walleye only after being assured by a distributor that it was European walleye.

Wentz said his company feels it was misled and said, “if we had known, we wouldn’t have purchased it.”

The Majors and Spectators chain has since made sure it is purchasing only walleye.

Other restaurants also claimed they were misled.

But some food distributors denied wrongdoing.

Jim Walstrom, the president of Morey’s Seafood, displayed restaurant invoices that showed fish labeled as zander, not walleye.

“We make responsible decisions for our own business, how we market our products,” Walstrom said. “How someone else chooses to market it is beyond our control.”

Back to top


At age 96, Backus man is still hunting
This fall, 28 Minnesota deer hunting licenses were issued to 90-year-olds


By Dennis Anderson
Star Tribune

MINNEAPOLIS (AP) – Question: How many deer-hunting licenses did the Department of Natural Resources issue to 96-year-old Minnesotans this fall?

If your guess is “zero,” you’d be wrong – but understandably so. Deer hunting, after all, though enjoyable, often is no walk in the park: Temperatures during the season are low. Distances that must be traveled can be long. And snow sometimes is deep.

For those reasons and others, even ardent hunters often hang up their guns in their 70s. Fewer still are hunting in their 80s. And only a relative handful of hunters are in the field at age 90 and beyond.

Still, four 96-year-old Minnesotans purchased hunting licenses this fall: LeRoy Tilbury of Backus, Edward Schoenborn of Mahnomen, Alvin Holmberg of Willmar and Gunnar Erickson of Grand Marais.

A fifth deer hunter, John Trebnick, of Bovey won’t be 96 until Dec. 26.

In all, 28 deer hunting licenses were issued in Minnesota this fall to hunters 90 years of age and older, according to DNR records. Included were two 93-year-old women, Myrtie Hunt of Bemidji and Gladys Prussia of Twin Valley.

Of these, Tilbury is the patriarch – the oldest deer hunter in the state.

Born Feb. 23, 1908, during what he recalls today as “the winter of the blue snow,” Tilbury, amazingly, does not wear glasses – nor has he ever. “I can read the newspaper or shoot a rifle at a target 100 yards away without them,” he said.

And, yes, Tilbury did shoot a buck this fall, felling the animal with his pump action Remington .270. The deer was not big, but has been a good eater, Tilbury said, and was an animal he skinned and butchered himself.

“Venison and moose are my favorites to eat,” he said.

Tilbury lives alone outside of Backus in north-central Minnesota on a parcel just shy of 30 acres. His wife of 52 years has been dead about two decades. They had nine sons and two daughters, some of whom live nearby.

Tilbury, however, a former “logger and saw-miller” who has hunted a lot of game in many different places, relies largely on himself.

“I only own 27 acres now,” he said. “But I used to own four 40s. I bought some of that land for $2 to $4 an acre. I’m sorry I ever sold any of it. If I hadn’t, I’d be rich today.”

Tilbury’s parents were born in Iowa, and after moving north, his father supported his family by working in the woods.

Come autumn, as a boy, LeRoy accompanied his father to hunt deer. When he was “13 or 14,” the younger Tilbury killed two deer in one season – until recently one of the few years in his life, he said, that was legal.

“Having game to eat was important to our family when I was young,” Tilbury said. “But even as a boy, we were lawful. We respected game laws.”

Tilbury’s work as a timberman took him west in 1938, to California, where – regrettably to him – he cut the giant redwoods.

“Those were beautiful trees and it was a shame to cut them,” he said. “I was out there for about three years, maybe a little more. I also hunted that country for deer and elk.”

Timber cutting later took Tilbury to Oregon and Montana, where he also hunted. He also has traveled to Florida, Mexico, Texas and Canada seeking game. Asked why he still hunts, Tilbury speaks first of his love of venison. But there’s more.

“To be in the woods and feel free, that’s it,” he said. “That’s what I love about deer hunting.

“When you’re in the woods, you go by the rules of nature and the game laws. You have to have steady nerves. If you see a deer that isn’t legal, you leave it. But if you see a legal deer, well, that’s the point.”

Tilbury is unsure why he has lived so long. Nothing about his personal habits or practices, he said, would suggest he might live to see 100 years of age or beyond.

“It’s a gift of God, I guess,” he said. “He’s got control, I always figure. When He says you’ve lived long enough, that’s it. You take two guys and they’re both healthy, and one guy makes it to 100, but the other only lives to 25. Why that is, I don’t know. I just think you’re born and your days are numbered.”

Possible as it is that Tilbury has another deer season in him, and perhaps another and another still, he’ll never take a deer closer to home than he did this year.

“I shot my deer right out the back door,” he said. “One of my sons was here at my house, and I looked out the window and I said, ‘There’s a deer.’ I told my son, ‘Come here and hold the door.’ I got my gun, and that’s how I shot my deer this year, with my son holding the door.

“Which is good, because I can’t get around like I used to.”

Back to top

© 2004 Outdoor Outlines, Inc.